After Evelyn starts to get the lovesick blues, Riley tracks down Evelyn’s old girlfriend from before she died, and brings her onto the show.
+Transcript
Evelyn: And you're sure we won't be having anymore close encounters of the Todd kind this episode?
Riley: Nope, I can literally never guarantee that, but we managed to at least patch up the wall, so how about we all just live in hope?
Evelyn: It sucks how he can just make himself appear anywhere.
Riley: Yup. The unskippable ad.
Evelyn: Do you think he ever gets bored of bothering people all the time?
Riley: Evelyn, if Todd were capable of boredom, life as himself would be unliveable. It'd be like being a peanut with a deadly nut allergy.
Evelyn: It always makes me feel weird when you say “nut.”
Riley: Then how about we keep our nuts to ourselves and move on?
Evelyn: Good idea! Man, we’re really off to a great start! Let’s do the-
[Intro]
Evelyn: Intro! [Beat] Hey everybody! If you’re listening to this, statistically, you're either driving, jogging, or on the toilet! Hopefully not any combination of the three!
Riley: Although we have the technology, we have yet to create a ransom note composed only of Kidz Bop lyrics. I'm just saying, kidnappers, that's gotta be worth at least a few extra bucks. Hi everyone, I’m Riley, your best whatever the fuck.
Evelyn: And I’m Evelyn: Your Ghost Host with the Most! Do you wanna tell the listeners what the topic is today, Riles?
Riley: Uhm, yes, but instead of me, it should be you.
Evelyn: Today, we’re going retro - that’s right, Evelyn’s territory - to rate every single Digimon in order of both colourfulness and huggability.
Riley: [In emotional pain] Yep, indeed we are. But first, Evelyn, I need to discuss something serious with you.
Evelyn: Oh no! Are you more of a Pokemon fan!?
Riley: No, I think they're all stupid. Uh, I mean, no. I was more, uh, into collecting those Yogi Bear cards or whatever the fuck they were called - you know, the vaguely Egyptian ones? POINT IS! This is about Jon, and I don't think we can afford to ignore it any longer.
Evelyn: What? Did he get a haircut!? I’d feel terrible if I forgot to compliment him on it.
Riley: Worse, I think he’s in a bad place.
Evelyn: I mean, it is your bathroom. A rat got in there once and it was just eaten by a bigger rat, which you then ate.
Riley: No, not like that, I mean emotionally. He’s been even more depressed recently, especially since Brains Vincent released that diss track about me that calls him boring. I mean, between you and me, I’m pretty sure I saw him fashioning a ghost noose earlier.
Evelyn: Not a ghost noose! Wait, how do you make a ghost noose?
Riley: Doesn’t matter! He needs your help, Ev.
Evelyn: Right, we’ll pause the podcast, this is a more pressing matter. You coming, Riley?
Riley: Nah, I better not. The whole “eating him alive and damning his soul to my shitter” thing kinda put a damper on our rapport. This is an Evelyn job.
Evelyn: That’s fair. Okay, I'll be right back!
SOUND: Evelyn phases through the wall.
Riley: [Stage Whisper] Alright everyone, Jon isn’t actually depressed - well he is, but no more than usual, I just needed an excuse to get Evelyn out of the room for a bit. Remember a few episodes back, when your Ghost host with the Most said I'd probably end up in hell, cause apparently I'm “selfish” and “needlessly homicidal”? Well, she was fucking wrong, and I'm gonna prove it. How?
SOUND: Riley moves closer to the mic
Riley: [smug] Let’s just say your best ghoulfriend got in contact with Evelyn’s old girlfriend from years back - you know, the one who saw her get splattered all over Chad Kroeger in 2004 - yeah, she’s coming on the show.
And you know what? It's gonna be a big, heartwarming reunion, and Evelyn is gonna be so happy she'll have to eat her stupid-ass words. Just gotta keep her distracted until Olivia shows up. Get the tissues ready, folks, this one’s gonna be more heartwarming and inspirational than every Oscar-Bait cinematic turd combined.
This episode will probably be a little shorter than usual, but that doesn't matter, cause it's gonna be so emotionally uplifting that you'll probably wanna listen to it ten times in a row anyway.
SOUND: Evelyn phases out of the bathroom
Riley: Oh hey Ev, how’d it go?
Evelyn: [Irritated] Riley, he’s not suicidal, he’s just ticked off and sexually frustrated.
Riley: Aren’t we all?
Evelyn: You had me really worried about him! Why would you lie like that?
Riley: Well, we could make a whole-ass episode about my fuck-ups, or we could talk about…. Hugging digicorn.
Evelyn: It’s Digimon, Riley, short for Digital Monsters. Haven't you heard the rap?
Riley: I genuinely think I'd rather die. Anyway, which one is the most huggable?
Evelyn: [Angry] It’s Terriermon, but that’s not the point!
Riley: Fine fine, I’m sorry. I’ll make it up to you soon.
Evelyn: It’s always soon with you, Riley, when are you gonna take responsibility for your actions?
Riley: When I’m dead, preferably.
Evelyn: Ugh, you’ll never change.
Riley: [Smugly] I don’t know, I’m surprising sometimes.
Evelyn: What's that supposed to mean?
Riley: [Even smugger] I don't know, but maybe all will be revealed in time
Evelyn: What!?
Riley: All I'm saying is, Evelyn, I have some hidden depths. What you see isn't always what you get when it comes to the Riley Almanzor experience. I contain multitudes.
Evelyn: Of small animals.
Riley: No! I mean, yes, but that's not what I'm referring to. I'm a complex individual, is what I'm saying.
Evelyn: Well, in that case, let's take a look at what kind of individual you are - with this online personality Quiz I found.
Riley: What kind of online quiz? It's not one of those bullshit Myers-Briggs tests, is it?
Evelyn: No, no, no, it's much more scientific than that. This is the “Which Digimon Are You?” Quiz from Buzzfeed.
Riley: Great. Wonderful. We’re back to this. Also [Riley leans into the mic] Which one of you narcs told Evelyn about Buzzfeed?
Evelyn: We’ll post the link to the quiz on twitter so people can see what their results are. But first, Riley, it's your turn.
Riley: My excitement knows no bounds.
Evelyn: Okay so, first question: Pick a Pokémon - the options are Articuno, Zapdos, Moltres, Bulbasaur, Charmander, Squirtle, Eevee, Jigglypuff, Pikachu, Mewtwo, Mew, and Magikarp.
Riley: First of all, that's too many options. Leave it at six, folks. Secondly, let me have a look at the pictures.
Evelyn: Make sure you choose wisely.
Riley: So, what do we have here? Bird, bird, burning bird, Chernobyl frog, Chernobyl lizard, happy tortoise, big-eyed snack thing, Marshmallow, the over-marketed one, the thicc one, the thicc one’s dork nephew, and nam flashback fish. They all look pretty stupid, but I'm gonna go for the thicc one.
Evelyn: Mewtwo! Okay, next question: What color are your eyes? Blue, brown, green, or gray?
Riley: This quiz is blatantly ghoulist.
Evelyn: I’m just gonna pick gray, considering that's what the rest of you is.
Riley: [Sighs] Fine.
Evelyn: Next question: Pick a show. The options are Bojack Horseman, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Parks and Recreation, Rick and Morty, The Good Place, and The Office.
Riley: I mean these are all too mainstream for me, but I feel like I've got an extremely high IQ so let's go Rick and Morty.
Evelyn: What letter does your name start with? So that'll be R. Now choose an emoji: Options are upside down smiley face, poop, middle finger, the “okay” sign, scared face, and quizzical face.
Riley: Middle finger.
Evelyn: What color are your socks? You don't wear socks, so we’ll just say “none.”
Riley: This quiz is fucking stupid.
Evelyn: The next question is “Did you get drunk last weekend?” I'm gonna put “Nope” cause I know for a fact you spent last weekend trying to appeal your Reddit shadowban.
Riley: That sham of a website trying to silence the truth about JFK isn't something I can take lying down.
Evelyn: Now, pick a dog from this selection of very good boys.
Riley: I'd eat literally any of these dogs.
Evelyn: I'm not fully comfortable with you framing the question like that, Riley, but if you had to choose just one?
Riley: Uhhh, you're putting me on the spot here. Maybe the one with the party hat? He's got the most meat on him.
Evelyn: Hmm. Don't like that. Anyway, final question! Which season were you born in?
Riley: Summer.
Evelyn: Aaaand done! You got Garudamon.
Riley: Holy shit, that's one buff chicken.
Evelyn: The description is “There's nothing more important to you than fairness and order, and people really admire you for that.”
Riley: I hate how dead-on that is. Except for people admiring me.
Evelyn: Hey, I admire you!
Riley: Yeah, and you're gonna admire me even more real soon.
Evelyn: Gosh, what is with you today? You keep making these weird, vague statements.
Riley: I don't know what you're talking about, Ev. But someone might…
Evelyn: See! You just did it again! You're up to something, Almanzor, and I'm gonna get to the bottom of it!
Riley: Hey Evelyn, tell me about your favorite episode of Middle Aged Tree Men.
Evelyn: I’ve been preparing my entire afterlife for this. So in season 6, episode 13, Redwood and Silverbirch are just about to confront the evil Ted Burner whose irresponsible brush fires have been endangering the Autumn Olive kids!
[WEIRD AD TIME]
SOUND: Upbeat steel drum music playing in the background.
Fish Lady: These days, it feels like it's harder to get a date than ever, what with rampant pollution, overfishing, and the fall of Rapture. But those issues are a thing of the past, thanks to PlentyOfFishPeople.com! Join the only dating site made for and by the denizens of the eight seas! That’s right, we’re counting the bleakest fathoms too!
Whether you've got a fish torso, fish legs, a fish face, or even just a fish fetish, you're eligible for membership. We’re committed to making fairytale romances like The Little Mermaid, The Shape of Water, and Eel Soup come true, and if you sign up for a free membership on our site, all of this could be yours!
Ariel: When I first fell for Erik, all my friends and family told me it'd never work, but when we hooked up on PlentyOfFishPeople.com, all our dreams came true. Isn't that right, Eric?
Erik: [Terrified, drowning screams]
Tanenbaum: Thanks to PlentyOfFishPeople.com I was able to meet tall, dark, and handsome here. For a long time I’ve had a big daddy kink, so I’m really getting the best of both worlds.
SOUND: Big daddy noise.
Warner: What the hell!? All I’m getting are Catfish, and you know what? I love it. I FUCKING LOVE IT!
Fish Lady: Join PlentyOfFishPeople.com today and at long last, you can find your Nemo.
Erik: [Drowned screaming slowly dies down]
SOUND: Upbeat steel drums continue, then fade.
[END OF WEIRD AD TIME]
Evelyn: -And then, in 1989, the infamous Mary Iguana had just killed Ronnie Raygun, changing the course of the forest forever!
Riley: [Uh huh-ing numerous times] [Obviously in mental agony] Really, and when did Morby come into this?
Evelyn: Morby wasn’t in the original show, Riley, he was a universe consuming cosmic horror.
Riley: Oh yeah. I miss Morby.
SOUND: Doorbell chimes.
Evelyn: Oh dang, now we’re gonna have to edit this part out, and it was such a good story!
Riley: Firstly, when have we ever edited anything out of this damn podcast, and secondly [smugly] I don’t think we’ll need to do that at all.
Evelyn: Riley! Did you order food again!?
Riley: Nope, even better. [Beat] Sorry, Bubba.
SOUND: Riley walking upstairs.
Riley: [Mock curious; cocky] Now who could that be?
SOUND: Riley opens up the door.
Olivia: Uh, hi. I’m here for the job interview? Am I in the right place? This doesn't look like a Goldman Sachs branch...
Evelyn: [Completely taken aback] Oh my fuck.
Riley: Yeah, I get that all the time, we’ve been outsourcing to basements a lot more since 2008. Right this way.
Evelyn: oh my god oh my god ohmygod.
Olivia: I brought a copy of my resume for you to look over.
SOUND: Riley takes the paper
Riley: Oh wow, this is very informative. Excellent credentials.
Olivia: You’re holding it upside down.
Riley: Oh am I? Very good, you passed the first test.
Olivia: I...
Evelyn: Riley that’s... Oh my god it’s really her... How did you..?
Riley: So Olivia, I’m gonna need to ask you a few questions about your past relationship history
Olivia: You mean work history?
Riley: ...No.
Evelyn: Riley!? Stop ignoring me - how did you make this happen?
Riley: But first, Olivia, I think you should go to the bathroom.
Olivia: ...Why?
Riley: I mean, this is a really important interview, you don’t wanna risk any ...accidents.
[BEAT]
Olivia: ...Okay.
Riley: Don’t forget to wash your hands.
SOUND: Olivia gets up and goes to the bathroom.
Riley: Alright, so what did you want to talk ab-
Evelyn: RILEY, WHY IS SHE HERE, HOW IS SHE HERE, HOW DID YOU-
Riley: Ev, Relax! Just don’t think about it.
Evelyn: IT’S A LITTLE HARD NOT TO THINK ABOUT.
Riley: Look, I set this little reunion up because I wanted to do something nice for you. And to lower my apparent chances of going to hell, but it was mostly for you!
Evelyn: Riley, I haven’t seen her in 16 years, what am I gonna say?
Riley: That’s the genius of the “interview,” whatever you wanna say, I’ll say it in the form of a question.
Evelyn: [Choking up] Riley this is so… Thank you. You’re an amazing friend.
Riley: [Smugly] Oh, just you wait.
SOUND: Olivia comes out of the bathroom and sits down.
Olivia: So, on with the interview?
Riley: Well, for my first question...
Evelyn: It's been so long, how have you been?
Riley: How are you?
Olivia: I’m uh, fine.
Evelyn: [Becoming overwhelmed with happiness] I’ve missed you so much… You look so different!
Riley: You, uh, look very experienced.
Olivia: I like to consider myself as such, yes.
Evelyn: I’ve thought about you everyday, for the past 16 years, I just.. I can’t believe you’re here!
Riley: I uh, think you’d be very good for this position.
Olivia: [Incredulously] I’m still not completely sure what “this position” is.
Evelyn: I… I think I still love you.
Riley: Alright, I’ve got nothing for that one.
Olivia: Excuse me?
Evelyn: I mean, that’s not to say I ever stopped, but… Gosh this is just so much, we have so much to talk about! So much to relearn about each other!
Riley: You’re uh… You seem to be… uh.
Olivia: Look, I don’t think this is going to work out.
Riley: What, why?
Olivia: Well, for one, most Goldman-Sachs managers don’t have their mom answer the door.
Riley: How do you know? You’ve never worked for us before, we’re a family business!
Olivia: You said your name was Almanzor!
Riley: Goldman-Sachs is my...street name?
Olivia: Look, I think I’m just gonna leave.
SOUND: Olivia stands up.
Evelyn: Wait, no!
Riley: [Panicked] Woah, just wait a second, there’s no need to-
Olivia: To what? Leave? Or do you suggest I sit back down so you can keep making vague statements and waste more of my time?
Riley: That’s not what I was doi-
Olivia: Oh I can assure you it was. I don’t know if this was some sick prank or something, but whatever it was, I don’t want any part of it. I’m leaving.
Evelyn: No! I can’t lose her again!
Riley: Olivia, I really think you shou-
Evelyn: I’m sorry, Riley!
Riley: Wait, what!?
SOUND: Weird ghost noises as Evelyn possesses Riley’s body.
Olivia: [Confused/concerned] What the..
Riley/Evelyn: Liv, please don’t leave!
Olivia: I already told you I wa- Wait. What did you just call me?
Riley/Evelyn: Your full name is Olivia Anne Baker, you pick your nails when you’re nervous, you only passed English 103 because you bribed the nerdy kid in class for his notes, and you’ve only ever let two people call you Liv: your grandpa, and me.
Olivia: How do you…
Riley/Evelyn: Liv… it’s me, Evelyn.
Olivia: Evy!? But you’re.. You..
Riley/Evelyn: Died? Yeah, I’ve been a ghost for about 16 years now, I’ve been haunting Riley here ever since they ate my corpse.
Olivia: I’m… gonna ignore that last part. God, it’s so nice to hear your voice again. Well, not technically your voice, but you know what I mean.
SOUND: Olivia hugs Evelyn.
Riley/Evelyn: So, uh, what've you been up to?
Olivia: [Gives a small laugh] What, for the last sixteen years?
Riley/Evelyn: Yeah, anything happen?
Olivia: I mean, yeah, a lot, it’s been sixteen fucking years, Evy.
Riley/Evelyn: Well, are you still doing art stuff? I still have that dog doodle you drew on that cocktail napkin in my drawer! I was gonna get a tattoo of it before, well, the splat.
Olivia: [Amused; teasingly] Wow, you getting a tattoo? I really was a bad influence on you
Riley/Evelyn: [Teasing] The worst.
Olivia: God, that was so many years ago, only memorable part of that trip.
Riley/Evelyn: Oh Malibu wasn’t all that bad! I mean, remember when we went to the beach really early in the morning and we saw those dolphins?
Olivia: Yeah, I remember that. [Giggles] You tried to swim after them before the tide knocked you on your ass.
SOUND: They both laugh.
Riley/Evelyn: I’m sorry. You know, about getting all squished.
Olivia: I mean, It’s not your fault, Evy.
Riley/Evelyn: [Solemnly] I just, I’ve always wondered what seeing that did to you. I was afraid it scarred you for life.
Olivia: It does rank pretty high on my list of the most fucked up moments of my life.
Riley/Evelyn: Higher than when that clown tried to tase you in Quiznos?
Olivia: It’s a close second.
Riley/Evelyn: I hope it didn’t ruin Nickelback for you! I know back in the day you were an even bigger fan than me.
Olivia: [Regretful] Yeah... Not my finest moment.
Riley/Evelyn: Wait what?
Olivia: I kinda grew out of Nickelback at the end of my twenties.
Riley/Evelyn: Oh… Well that’s fine, love is all about compromise, after all.
Olivia: What do you mean, Evy?
Riley/Evelyn: You know, picking up where we left off? I know things have changed - you're forty; I’m dead. But people have overcome bigger differences.
Olivia: [Lightly] Evelyn I don’t think that’s going to work..
Riley/Evelyn: Why? I mean, I still love you, and, I’ve thought about this moment for so long.
Olivia: [Lightly] I’m married, Evelyn.
Riley/Evelyn: I… You’re.. What?
Olivia: I’m married, have been for about 8 years now.
[BIG BEAT]
Riley/Evelyn: Oh..
Olivia: She and I met ten years ago at some shitty dive bar over in Apalachicola. We just started talking and we clicked. She helped me get through a lot after what had happened at the concert.
Riley/Evelyn: [Heartbroken] I… I see...
Olivia: [Sincerely] Evelyn, what we had was special, and I never regretted a second of it, but... You died.
Riley/Evelyn:[Choking up] Yeah.. I did… I… Think I’m gonna go to the bathroom now.
Olivia: [Somewhat confused] But Evy, you’re a ghost.
Riley/Evelyn: Yeah… I know…
SOUND: Ghost noises as Evelyn un-possesses Riley and goes to the bathroom.
Riley: [Groggily/Dazed and confused] WHAT.
Olivia: I think this was a mistake.
Riley: WHAT!?
Olivia: Thanks for.. Setting this up. Make sure she’s safe, okay?
SOUND: Olivia leaves up the stairs.
Riley: [BEAT] WHAT? WHAT HAPPENED? DO I GET TO GO TO HEAVEN NOW?
[END]